East of Chicago

East of Chicago, located on 275 N Market St in Shreve, Ohio, offers a delightful array of pizza options that has quickly garnered a loyal following. Known for their 6-inch and 9-inch Flash Pan Pizzas, patrons rave about the 7 Layer Veggie and All Meat varieties. Signature options like BBQ Chicken and Buffalo Chicken deliver satisfying flavors at reasonably priced menu items, typically around $7 for a 6-inch pizza and $13.99 for a 9-inch. Customer reviews highlight the warm hospitality and prompt service provided by the staff, with one customer noting, "Quite literally the NICEST people." Diners appreciate the high-quality toppings and generous portions, particularly praising the pan crust for its perfect balance of crispiness and softness. Marilyn Anderson enjoyed the taco pizza, although she expressed some concern about changes in portion size, while Jyle McCluggage emphasized the must-try chicken bacon ranch sub. Despite minor technical hiccups like a malfunctioning TV, guests leave satisfied with both the food and the overall atmosphere. East of Chicago excels in delivering not just excellent pizza, but also a welcoming experience, making it a standout choice for pizza lovers in the area.